The finest homemade ice cream, ice cream waffle cones, ice cream cake, and ice cream pies
available in the lower Hudson Valley region! • Hours: Aug 12-9 everyday; Sep 1-Oct 30 Mon-Tue-Wed 12-8, Thu-Sun 12-9 • Open Labor Day and Columbus day 12-8PM
Trip Advisor ranks Bellvale Creamery #2 among Top 10 Ice Cream Parlor’s in the United States!

2009, 2020

Fall Hours Monday-Wednesday 12 pm-8 pm & Thursday-Sunday 12 pm -9 pm

September 20th, 2020|0 Comments

Vanilla

Chocolate

Strawberry

Cookies & Cream(Contains gluten)

Coffee(Coffee ice cream with cappuccino pieces)

Cookie Dough(Contains gluten)

Butter Pecan(contains nuts)

Coconut-(Coconut ice cream with chocolate covered almonds)

Pumpkin

Pistachio (contains nuts)

Mint Chip

Great White Way(White chocolate ice cream with raspberry sauce and dark chocolate chunks)

Calf Trax(Vanilla ice cream with peanut butter swirl and mini peanut butter cups)-Contains peanuts

Salty Caramel Crunch(Vanilla ice cream with salty caramel swirl and butter candy(Contains NO nuts)

Bellvale Bog(Dark chocolate ice cream with brownie chunks and fudge swirl) Contains gluten

S’mores(S’mores ice cream with fudge swirl and mini marshmallows)Contains Gluten

BlackBerry Blackout(Red Raspberry ice cream with chocolate cookie swirl)Contains Gluten & soy)

Pineapple sorbet

Low Carb Maple Bourbon

Greek Style Frozen Yogurt

Open daily from 12 noon!

Bellvale Creamery on the top of Mount Peter is a “must-stop,” even for hikers on the Appalachian Trail, which passes through from New Jersey into Harriman State Park. Their ice cream is beyond fabulous, attests this writer – homemade – with dangerously addictive, yummy flavors, (one with chunks of fudge inside) and the view over Warwick is great. –

Bellvale Creamery Menu

Bellvale Farms Menu Board
Trip Advisor Travelers' Choice Award-Bellvale Farms

Walkup Window Only Is Open

Incredible Flavors

The Creamery is located at 1390 Route 17A, Warwick, NY. Open April 1 through October 30. Open at noon every day; closing time depends on the season. Featuring homemade ice cream served in cones, sundaes, or homemade waffles cones. 50 flavors, plus ice cream cakes, pies, and take-home quarts!

Please Note: We love your pets as much as you do but we don’t love them inside the creamery. For safety of all, only service dogs are allowed inside the building.

200-year-old Warwick farm is a family affair

Two hundred years is an awful long time, but that’s how long Bellvale Farms has been in existence. The farm is located in the hamlet of Bellvale, in the Town of Warwick. “Actually, it didn’t even have a name at the beginning,” says Al Buckbee, sitting in the kitchen with Judy, his wife of 55 years. “But it’s been in our family all that time.” A plaque outside dates the place to 1819.

“This was my father’s, and we bought it from him in 1971,” Al says. “We raised our family here.”That family includes son Skip, a former Orange County Legislator, who runs the farm, and daughter Amy, who operates the well-known Bellvale Farms Creamery with her husband, Tim Noteboom.

“I always wanted be a farmer and assumed I would be,” says Al. “But right out of college, I took a job on Wall Street. At first I worked there Monday to Friday and then was a farmer on weekends.”

“In other words, he worked all the time,” Judy says.

“That’s not true,” Al says, laughing. “For a few years I played golf on Tuesday nights.”

In 1995 Al retired and became a full-time farmer. Today, Bellvale Farms is one of the last working dairy farms in Orange County, with 460 acres of land and more than 150 dairy cows.

The cows are milked at 6 a.m. and 6 p.m., and a truck pulls up once every two days to take the product to be pasteurized and homogenized. Some of the milk is sold, while some goes back to the creamery to be made into ice cream. Semi-automatic milking equipment speeds the process.

“Before machines, we needed six people a day,” Al says. “Now, one person can operate six units.”

Film directors and producers have also discovered the farm’s gorgeous location, with Bearfort Ridge close by and Sugar Loaf Mountain off in the distance. The “Sneaky Pete” and “An American Saga” TV series have shot there, and lots of TV commercials have been made at Bellvale Farms.

“Too many to count,” says Judy. “My favorite was the Fruit of the Loom characters running around dressed up like fruit. Apple asked us to plant a cornfield, and they will be up here in October.”

Al grew up there, playing and exploring the land, originally part of the Wisner Farm.

“I wasn’t the first baby born at St. Anthony’s Hospital, but one of the first,” he says. “I hadn’t been back to any hospital until 2016 when I had two knee surgeries. I told the doc I was back for repairs,” he adds.

“And I was born in Kingman, Kansas,” Judy says, proudly. “I’m the daughter of a wheat farmer.”

They met and fell in love at Kansas State University in Manhattan, Kansas. Al graduated in 1963 and Judy in 1965. They found time to get married at Warwick Reformed Church in 1964.

“That was a long time ago,” Judy says.

“Our reception was at the Iron Forge Inn,” Al says. “When we had our anniversary party there 50 years later, there was a much bigger crowd than our original crowd.”

With the 200th anniversary of the farm approaching, the couple has plans.

“We’re having a party on July 14 and inviting everyone who helps keep this farm running,” Judy says. “Roofers, plumbers, electricians, hay farmers, grain farmers. It’s invitation only because we want to keep it small.”

“All these people are integral to running a farm,” Judy says. “And we want to thank them all.”

John DeSanto is a freelance photojournalist. Find more of his 845LIFE stories, photos and videos at recordonline.com. Reach John at jjdesanto@gmail.com

Appalachian Trail Community Supporter


Official recharging station for A.T. hikers’ devices, canteens, and relaxation!


The first section of the A.T. opened in Warwick in 1931, six years before the official opening of the entire Appalachian Trail. The Town has been welcoming hikers ever since and was named an A.T. Community™ in 2012.

The Town of Warwick is centrally located on the A.T. between High Point in New Jersey to the west and the Bear Mountain Bridge in New York to the east with easy road access to this entire 65 mile section. The Village of Greenwood Lake in Warwick with many hiker amenities can be accessed directly from the A.T. using the Village Vista Trail. The Pochuck, Wawayanda and Wildcat Shelters on the AT are easily accessed from Warwick and can be used in planning section hikes (no reservations or permits required).

With ample road access and parking within and in the immediate vicinity of Warwick, A.T. hikes of all ability levels can be accommodated. The Wallkill River National Wildlife Reserve, the Pochuck Boardwalk and suspension bridge, the “Stairway to Heaven” at Wawayanda Mountain, spectacular views of the Warwick Valley and Greenwood Lake, and Fitzgerald Falls are all within Warwick or at our immediate doorstep, literally just a few minutes away in neighboring towns. A little further within a 45-minute drive is the beautiful Delaware Water Gap, the clear and clean waters of the upper Delaware River, the NY-NJ Trail Conference’s spectacular  Bear Mountain A.T. rehabilitation project featuring over 1,000 hand-hewn granite steps, and the Bear Mountain Bridge which carries the A.T. across the Hudson River built in 1924.