Creamery Ice Cream Store

Ice Cream Cakes & Pies • Ice Cream Sandwiches
Pre-Packed Containers

Great white way pie

Great White Way
Ice Cream Pie

Price: $32.55
Serves: 8-10

  • Great White Way (white chocolate ice cream with raspberry swirl and dark chocolate chunks)
Bellvale Creamery Ice Cream Pie

Bellvale Bog
Ice Cream Pie

Price: $32.55
Serves: 8-10

  • Bellvale Bog (dark chocolate ice cream with fudge and brownie dough)

Ice Cream Sandwiches

Price: $12.60 for six ice cream sandwiches

Oreo® cookie with either vanilla or chocolate ice cream; six in a package

Bellvale Creamery Quart

Pre-Packed Ice Cream


  • $12.60 per Quart or
  • $73.50 per 2.5 Gallon Tub Vanilla
  • $84.00 per 2.5 Gallon Tub Other Flavors

Available in limited flavors, because we are a handcrafted creamery and only make small batches. Please inquire in advance about available flavors which may change on a daily basis. Thank you!

Ice Cream CakesBellvale Farms Ice Cream Cake


  • Small cake: $18.90 (serves 4-8)
  • Large Cake: $31.50 (serves 10-12)
  • Party size cake: $36.75 (serves 20-25)

Chocolate cookie crunch with layer of vanilla and chocolate ice cream.


  • Cakes are finished with white buttercream.
  • We use edible images for Birthday, Mother’s & Father’s Day, Graduation.
  • We don’t write on the cake. If you prefer your cake can be finished with white buttercream and you can add your own message with cake gel purchased from a third party or one of the local grocery stores

Custom Cakes

Custom cakes can be made with any hard ice cream currently in production, and using the same sizes described above. Cake will be one flavor and includes what is in the selected ice cream flavor. Note: We need a week’s notice to put a custom cake together.