Ice Cream Flavors at Bellvale Creamery

Please Note: As you know we are a small, family run business that makes a variety of high quality ice cream flavors in small batches. As a result, the flavors listed on the menu below may NOT always be available every day. So, if there is a particular favorite flavor of yours that you want to ensure is available on the day you visit us, please call us in advance; otherwise, we don’t want you to be disappointed that we may not have made enough of that flavor the day before! Thank you for your understanding and cooperation. We really appreciate it.Amy & Tim Noteboom

Allergen Warning

We are not peanut free. Tell your server if you have allergies, we will do our best to accommodate your requests.

(Note: Flavors listed below are subject to availability!)

  • Bellvale Bog: Dark chocolate ice cream with brownie dough and fudge swirl
  • Black Dirt Blast: Chocolate coffee ice cream with fudge and toffee pieces
  • Great White Way: White chocolate ice cream with dark chocolate chunks and raspberry swirl
  • Cheesecake: New York-style cheese cake ice cream with graham cracker swirl
  • S’mores: Graham cracker ice cream with marshmallow and chocolate swirl that takes you back to the campfire
  • In the Stix: French custard ice cream with Twix® candy bar pieces
  • Blueberries & Creme: Sweet creme ice cream with a blueberry swirl
  • Pumpkin: Made with real pumpkin and a touch of spice – just like pumpkin pie
  • Maple Cinnamon: Made with real maple syrup and fresh ground cinnamon
  • Barn Boots: Peanut brittle and marshmallow in chocolate ice cream
  • Meadow Muffins: Brownie pieces and peanut butter swirl in dark chocolate ice cream
  • Lick the Bowl: Cake batter ice cream with fudge swirl
  • Calf Trax: Vanilla ice cream with peanut butter swirl and mini peanut butter cups
  • After Dinner Mint: Mint ice cream, a hint of chocolate with chocolate-covered mint pieces

Pre-Packed Containers, Cakes & Pies

Ice Cream Cakes
We begin with a layer of vanilla ice cream, then a layer of chocolate ice cream with chocolate crunch inside.

NOTE: Orders for custom cakes require a one-week notice. Please call the Creamery at 845 988 1818 to place order and get more information.

Ice Cream Pies
Our delicious ice cream pies are available in two flavors: Great White Way (see description, left), in a graham cracker crust; and Bellvale Bog (see description, left), in a chocolate graham cracker crust.

Container Size Price
Quart $10
Ice Cream Pie $25
Small Cake (serves 4-6) $15
Large Cake (serves 12-15) $25
Party Size Cake (serves 20-25) $30

Frozen Dessert Facts

Frozen Yogurt
Not defined by the FDA but generally contains a yogurt component and yogurt culture or probiotics.

Ice Cream
Defined by FDA to have no less than 10% milk fat and no less than 20% milk solids.

Not defined by the FDA; it’s a frozen dessert made with water

Legally defined by the FDA; must have a minimum of 10% food and must contain egg yolk.

Not defined by FDA; generally made with milk, not cream.

The Creamery is located at 1390 Route 17A, Warwick, NY. Open April 1 through October 30. Open at noon every day; closing time depends upon the season.

Our home made ice cream (we make over 50 flavors) is served on a cone, a sundae, or in our homemade waffle cones!

Our ice cream is also available to take home in quarts, ice cream cakes in three sizes, and ice cream pies. Custom cakes require 7-10 day advance notice. We also offer sorbet, low carb ice cream, and yogurt.

Images at The Creamery